Confucianism: Obedience alone is not filial piety (CLASSIC OF FILIAL PIETY, CH. 15)
Confucian Wisdom
CNF-013
父有爭子,則身不陷於不義。故當不義,則子不可以不爭於父……從父之令,又焉得為孝乎!
— CLASSIC OF FILIAL PIETY, CH. 15 (諫諍)
"The father who had a son that would remonstrate with him would not sink into the gulf of unrighteous deeds. Therefore when a case of unrighteous conduct is concerned, a son must by no means keep from remonstrating with his father… Hence, since remonstrance is required in the case of unrighteous conduct, how can (simple) obedience to the orders of a father be accounted filial piety?"
Modern Translation & Meaning
"Loving your parents does not mean going along with something wrong. If a parent is about to do wrong, speak up kindly and respectfully, because you care."
Unlock Practical Action Steps
Access the daily reflection prompts, dinner discussion questions, and actionable relational exercises for this card—and 650+ others.
Join the Childing VaultDaily Relational Exercise
1. Personal Reflection: How does this ancient principle address the relational tensions in your household today?
2. Family Dialogue: A practical question to ask your parents or spouse tonight over dinner.
3. Micro-Habit: One tangible act of honor you can perform in under 5 minutes today.
Read more in these articles
Related cards
Gently advising and correcting parents
- Confucianism: If your parents are wrong (ANALECTS 4.18)Confucian Wisdom
- Gentle Correction for Parents (亲有过,谏使更)Deck 2: The Art of Honoring Parents
- Soft Voice and Warm Expression (怡吾色,柔吾声)Deck 2: The Art of Honoring Parents
- Patience and Tears of Love (谏不入,悦复谏)Deck 2: The Art of Honoring Parents
- Enduring Without Bitterness (号泣随,挞无怨)Deck 2: The Art of Honoring Parents
Classic of Filial Piety
- Confucianism: Taking care of your own health and safety is the first step in honoring your parents (CLASSIC OF FILIAL PIETY)Confucian Wisdom
- Confucianism: Living an honorable (CLASSIC OF FILIAL PIETY)Confucian Wisdom
- Confucianism: Every good character trait you will ever learn starts with how you treat your parents (CLASSIC OF FILIAL PIETY)Confucian Wisdom
Part of the Childing Universal Flashcard Engine